‘A steampunk Mr Tayto’: why Irish critics hate Netflix’s House of Guinness

The GuardianWednesday, October 1, 2025 at 5:00:03 AM
‘A steampunk Mr Tayto’: why Irish critics hate Netflix’s House of Guinness
The new Netflix series 'House of Guinness' has sparked a significant backlash from Irish critics, who have expressed strong disapproval, contrasting sharply with the positive reviews it has received from audiences in the US and UK. This divide highlights the cultural sensitivities surrounding portrayals of Irish identity and accents, raising questions about authenticity in media representation. The criticism underscores the importance of understanding local perspectives in global productions, especially when dealing with cultural icons.
— Curated by the World Pulse Now AI Editorial System

Was this article worth reading? Share it

Recommended Readings
Play Dirty review – Shane Black’s action comedy comeback is a blast
PositiveWorld Affairs
Shane Black makes a triumphant return to action comedy with 'Play Dirty,' featuring Mark Wahlberg and LaKeith Stanfield. This film marks a significant moment as it showcases Black's signature style, reminiscent of his earlier hit 'The Nice Guys.' With the rise of streaming platforms like Netflix, which have transformed the movie landscape, Black's comeback is not just a nostalgic trip but a refreshing addition to the genre. Fans of action comedies will find this film a delightful experience, blending humor and excitement seamlessly.
Play Dirty review – Shane Black’s action comedy comeback is a blast
PositiveWorld Affairs
Shane Black makes a triumphant return to action comedy with 'Play Dirty,' featuring Mark Wahlberg and LaKeith Stanfield. This film marks a significant moment as it showcases Black's signature style, reminiscent of his earlier hit 'The Nice Guys.' With the rise of streaming platforms like Netflix, which have transformed the movie landscape, Black's comeback is not just a nostalgic trip but a refreshing addition to the genre. Fans of action comedies will find this film a delightful experience, blending humor and excitement seamlessly.
‘If you get it wrong, it’s sacrilegious!’ TV’s problem with Irish accents
NeutralWorld Affairs
The challenges actors face when attempting to portray Irish characters have come to light, with notable examples like James Norton's anxiety over playing a Dubliner and Helen Mirren's viral impersonation. This highlights the complexity of mastering an Irish accent, which is often underestimated. Just as pouring a perfect pint of Guinness requires skill, so does delivering an authentic Irish accent. This discussion is important as it sheds light on the broader issue of representation and authenticity in the entertainment industry.
‘If you get it wrong, it’s sacrilegious!’ TV’s problem with Irish accents
NeutralWorld Affairs
The challenges actors face when attempting to portray Irish characters have come to light, with notable examples like James Norton's anxiety over playing a Dubliner and Helen Mirren's viral impersonation. This highlights the complexity of mastering an Irish accent, which is often underestimated. Just as pouring a perfect pint of Guinness requires skill, so does delivering an authentic Irish accent. This discussion is important as it sheds light on the broader issue of representation and authenticity in the entertainment industry.
Latest from World Affairs
If you want to understand Russia tomorrow, you can’t afford to miss Putin at Valdai
NeutralWorld Affairs
Vladimir Putin's upcoming address at the Valdai Discussion Club is a key event for anyone interested in understanding Russia's future direction. Historically, Putin has used this platform to outline shifts in his administration's priorities and share insights on significant global issues. This year's meeting promises to be particularly revealing, as it could provide clues about Russia's stance on various international matters, making it essential for analysts, policymakers, and anyone invested in global affairs to pay attention.
Women’s Cricket World Cup: Australia v New Zealand – live
NeutralWorld Affairs
Australia kicks off their title defense in the Women's Cricket World Cup against New Zealand in Indore. The match, held at Holkar Stadium, is set to start at 3 PM local time. This game is significant as it marks the beginning of the tournament for Australia, who are looking to maintain their championship status. Fans are encouraged to share their thoughts as the match unfolds.
Fuel leak blows cover for alleged Russian submarine off Gibraltar
NeutralWorld Affairs
A recent report from a Telegram channel, known for its ties to Russian intelligence, revealed that the Novorossiysk submarine from the Black Sea fleet encountered serious technical issues while operating near Gibraltar. This incident raised eyebrows, especially considering the submarine's potential risk of explosion and its subsequent surfacing, which inadvertently disclosed its location. The situation prompts questions about the submarine's presence in the area and what it signifies for regional security.
Mysterious, majestic; Sudan’s Nuba Mountains
NegativeWorld Affairs
The Nuba Mountains in Sudan are home to a secluded community that is currently facing challenges due to the arrival of the Rapid Support Forces (RSF). This situation is concerning for the thousands of internally displaced persons (IDPs) living in the area, as the RSF's presence raises fears of instability and conflict. Understanding the dynamics in this region is crucial, as it highlights the ongoing struggles faced by vulnerable populations and the need for humanitarian support.
'It's safe now': See students pulled from rubble of collapsed school
PositiveWorld Affairs
In a heartwarming turn of events, students in Indonesia were dramatically rescued from the rubble of their collapsed school. The footage of their safe extraction has captured the attention of many, highlighting the bravery of the rescuers and the resilience of the young survivors. This incident not only showcases the importance of safety measures in schools but also brings hope and relief to families and communities affected by such tragedies.
How Tony Blair went from post-Iraq ignominy to the heart of Trump's peace plan
PositiveWorld Affairs
Tony Blair, the former British prime minister, has been appointed by Donald Trump as the co-head of the Board of Peace, a new initiative aimed at overseeing the reconstruction of Gaza. This marks a significant shift for Blair, who faced considerable criticism following the Iraq War. His involvement in this peace plan highlights a renewed focus on addressing the ongoing conflict and rebuilding efforts in the region, which could lead to improved relations and stability.